The World 4 Realz

An Open-Letter Rant Regarding the Arbitrivial Nature of Human Beings.

  • Home
  • About
    • Andi-Roo
    • The Hubz (Jesse)
    • Privacy Policy
  • Blogging
    • Social Media
  • Entertainment
    • Books
    • Movies + TV
  • Family
    • Children
    • Divorce
    • Health
    • Marriage
    • Women’s Issues
  • Goals
    • Challenge: 3-Day Novel Contest
    • Challenge: A to Z
    • Challenge: NaNoWriMo & Camp NaNoWriMo
    • Finance
  • Happies
    • Inspirational
    • Religion
    • Self Improvement
  • Rants
    • Worst Day Ever
  • Writing & Creativity

Moral Dystopia

July 24, 2012 by Andi Brunett-Libecap 8 Comments

Share the joy
 Neighborhood Watch, If I Don't Call the Police, My Neighbor Will - Diamond Grade Sign, 24

This SHOULD read… “I’m not going to call the police because my neighbor will probably do it.”

I keep wondering what the hell is wrong with people. I ask why I seem to be the only one who is always willing to stop and help. I can’t understand why others aren’t as giving.

My mom says I have a crusader’s heart, and I look for battles, always “tilting at windmills”, making mountains out of molehills and fighting for the point-of-the-matter long after it even matters anymore.

My hubz says I just have really high standards to which I hold not only myself, but the rest of the world as well, and that if I don’t lighten up and let people off the hook, I’m going to die an early death.

They both say, “People are just people, you know?”

I say they are both right, but only to some degree, at which point they are both extremely WRONG. The point-of-the-matter ALWAYS matters. It doesn’t expire. That’s why it’s called “the point-of-the-matter”. Because it might be something small, but it represents something much, much bigger. Something important. Something it’s too hard to change, so everyone just instead looks away.

And why should I let people off the hook? If I don’t hold people accountable for messing things up, for refusing to make changes, for allowing horrible atrocities, who will? It seems I am a small voice of reason surrounded by insanity.

And yes, I know, people are just people. But shouldn’t they want to be MORE than “just” anything? And if they don’t, why shouldn’t I continue to be disappointed?

I believe the majority of humans currently suffer from Moral Dystopia,

a phrase I am borrowing from an article I read recently on this very topic: “Violence and Moral Dystopia on the L Train” by Bindu wiles ( ). In this article, the author describes a situation in which she witnesses some thug-looking guy beating up on another dude, while everyone else sits and watches — doing nothing to stop the tussle.

Train, black and white photoShe says,

“I shouldn’t have been the only one

to stand up on that train

and scream my head off

to get the violence to stop.”


In Jeff Goins’ new book
Wrecked: When a Broken World Slams into Your Comfortable Life, the Introduction describes a similar but non-violent lack of social empathy. He and his wife attend performances at which a local printer creates poster memorabilia. Missing their chance to buy one which bears the date of their anniversary, thus making it a special evening indeed, he offers various patrons the opportunity to sell their posters so he may present one to his wife. No one will budge. Everyone assumes someone else will step up and do the nice thing — get up off your poster and give it to someone, for no other reason than that it means something.

Wrecked: When a Broken World Slams into your Comfortable Life by Jeff Goins

He says,

“It seemed everyone was saying,

‘I’m sure someone

will do the right thing.

It’s just not me.’”

And why? Because, as Goins indicates, the patrons each offered a variation of,

“I’m sure someone will help you.”

Why is it so fucking hard for people to do what’s right? Even my hubz — the sweetest guy on the planet, truly — had to be chastised by me to stop and offer help to people on the side of the road. His reasoning was, “I’m sure they have a cell phone,” or, “I’m sure someone else is already on the way,” or, “I’m sure the police have already been contacted on their behalf.”

The thing is, I have been on the side of the road, stuck without a cell phone, wishing even one person would stop. It shouldn’t be such a damn surprise when finally somebody DOES step up and do the right thing. But it is. After so many cars whiz past, by the time one stops, it is a shock. I have ALMOST been trained to NOT expect kindness of heart and generosity of spirit.

This.

This is what I am most angry about. People who know me well say I am the angriest person they know. But THIS is why. Moral Dystopia. I am angry because you humans continue to disappoint me.

The Arc of the Moral Universe Is Long, but It Bends Toward Justice. Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. Bumper Sticker“We used to experience morality as imperatives.

The consequences of not doing the right thing

were not only social,

but deeply emotional and psychological.

We couldn’t bear to live with ourselves.

Now we experience morality more as a choice

that we can always change as circumstances call for it.

We tend to personalize our ideals.

And what you end up with

is a nation of ethical free agents.”

~James Davison Hunter as quoted by Maureen Dowd

What happened? Why is everyone so afraid to break the silence, to go the extra mile, to stand above the mediocre and be heroic? We’re given a chance to do the right thing almost every day. Why don’t we do it?

Morality frog figurines“You don’t want to be the outsider

who betrays the institution;

whistleblowers are always the weirdos.

There are so many ways to rationalize

doing the easy thing.

And it’s really easy for us to overlook

how our inaction to step up

and do even the simplest thing

leads to profoundly destructive consequences

in our society.”

Lawrence Lessig as quoted by Maureen Dowd

Wake the fuck up, people. Be the weirdo. Pick up the trash that isn’t yours. Give away your last whatever. Make the phone call that saves someone’s life. Run into the burning building.

Blake Snyder wrote a book called Save the Cat! The Last Book on Screenwriting You’ll Ever Need. It’s pretty terrific even if you aren’t writing a script. I’m using it with my novel. About the title of his book, he says,

Save The Cat! The Last Book on Screenwriting You'll Ever Need By Blake Snyder“I call it the “Save the Cat” scene.

They don’t put it into movies anymore.

And it’s basic.

It’s a scene where we meet the hero

and the hero DOES something

— like saving a cat —

that defines who he is

and makes us, the audience,

like him.”

Go do something. Save the cat. Make me like you.

Amazon Prime Membership link

 

Antivirus |
Internet Security | PC TuneUp Utilities

The end.

Filed Under: Happies, Rants Tagged With: accountability, hear no evil, horrible atrocities, Moral Dystopia, morality, morality choices, see no evil, speak no evil

5 comments
  Livefyre
  • Get Livefyre
  • FAQ
Sign in
+ Follow
Post comment
 
Link
Newest | Oldest
dadblunders
dadblunders 5pts

I have wondered for a long time about the lack of involvement of people. I understand that people are busy but I have a feeling these same people will be busy they day the die. I wonder if they will even notice if they are dead or they will just keep working straight through in their own personal purgatory without breaks for all eternity.  People have to stop and smell the coffee, roses and at times B.S. to figure out the world is a small place and we are all interconnected. If a person doesn't want to stop for some one on the side of the road, fine....but don't be the person that keeps on driving without at least picking up your cell phone and calling the police. Being heroic doesn't have to be hard it just has to be the moral guide we live by. It is the same guide that we tell our children they need to follow. If we don't do what we have been asking them to do we are hypocrites and unfortunately our children are destined to make the same mistakes we did....just my opinion of course.... Aaron

LadyCrossroad
LadyCrossroad 5pts

The perfect rant - you've put in words what I've been thinking and observing for a long time. I don't have the answer. Why don't people do the right thing? Why have the social norms changed to become so lax? Why isn't 'the right thing' enforced by social opprobrium anymore? I have no idea. I was married to one of the least empathetic men I've ever met. He knew what 'the right thing' was, but didn't care. It was awful. Awful to watch, awful to live with. But he's not alone, this disease has spread, and has, in fact, become the new norm in the world beyond our comfortable Western civilisation as well. Ironically, I've never heard the word 'empathy' so much. It's thrown about like 'imagination' used to be in the 1960s. All too often, it's only a word.  In such a world, 'doing the right thing' is often a revolutionary act. It can even be illegal and severely punished - look at Bradley Manning, Julian Assange and Wikileaks, who showed the whole world the nasty, evil and criminal things many of our governments were doing in our names. Yet they are the ones who are pursued and punished.  13 years ago, I left my cushy legal job in London and went to work as a humanitarian in Africa. People said to me: it's amazing, you're amazing, I couldn't do that. I didn't see it as such a big deal. I had no children to care for at home, I was a free agent and I had skills and a temperament that would be useful in humanitarian emergencies.  'But you can', I said, 'you can serve your community in a thousand ways without leaving your country. You can volunteer on Saturday, you can help homeless people, you can fundraise.' All too often I would get a mumble in response.  A generation or two ago, this would not have been necessary to say or write. What went so wrong?

Mary Wallace
Mary Wallace 5pts

First off, get out of my head. Just kidding. This sounds so much like me and has been the story of my life. My mother used to laugh. "Mary, the world isn't fair." But I inherited her heart. My father always said of her, "she has a gallant soul." She did indeed. Crusader, Windmill tilter and quixotic soul to the end. And mad as hell. As in crazy, but also angry. Guess who got all that and more in both departments. So, I understand, Andi-Roo and I am a scourge against complacency and banality. I loathe the la-di-das, could-give-a-shit attitudes of the not-caring. The post-modern attitudes of so-called ironic, jaded comics have worn thin, but there is no replacement. Caring is not funny, I guess. Now I'm in rant mode. I understand and appreciate exactly where you're coming from Andi-Roo.  Everything to me is serious, although I have fun with my life and live it to its fullest. I dare say that when I shuffle off this mortal coil, I will have lived enough. But I intend to keep living my life with the grace and passion and care for others that I was brought up to believe was the point. The point matters. It always matters. That's the point. <3

D.C.
D.C. 5pts

It's funny. I read this post and I immediately felt defensive, as if you had lumped me, the reader into a group of people to whom everyone with the exception of you belongs. I realize you're speaking in general terms - you can't possibly believe that every other person on the planet lacks conviction and empathy - and yet here I was, fingers poised over the keyboard to list instances in which I did the right thing. There are many. Of course there are just as many where I could not be bothered as well. Sure, I stopped and offered a lift to the woman at the bus stop whom I inadvertently soaked from head to toe when my car's tire hit a pot hole, but would I have stopped again to help someone on the side of the road with car trouble? No, I would not have.  Maybe you would have done so but I think, fuck, this is a city. Even someone stranded on the side of the road will be helped by a tow truck or a police officer within 15 minutes. Will I stop and help tourists puzzling over a map? Of course, every time, even if I'm running late. Will I stop a fight in the middle of the street? No, of course not, not if I don't know what the fight is about. I may call the police and there is a chance my boyfriend will step in but in a city where one of of best friends was just run over in a road rage incident and a gang member just opened fire on food court because of a beef with a member of a different gang, I draw the line at anything beyond stepping up if I see bullying or harassment, which I will try to stop. I personally have a very strict code when it comes to manners. I was brought up in that very old school Canadian value system that small towns still hang on to. Must say please and thank you every time you ask a questions that begins with May or Can. Must hold door open for whomever is behind you and allow them to pass first. Must allow seniors to go ahead of you in lines, take your seat, you do their yard work if they live beside you, etc. Men must give women seats, carry their things if they're walking with them, allow them to enter a room, elevator, etc before you, etc. I still follow all of these rules but I try (try but not always succeed:) ) not to judge when others do not do the same. If I allowed myself this luxury, I would end up feeling both self-righteous and incredibly exhausted/angry all the time. I guess what I'm saying is that some people don't care and some people do. Some people will stand up for what they think is right but it might not be the same thing that I think is right and they may have valid reasons for feeling that way. On another note, have you read Talk To The Hand by Lynne Truss? I think you would like it. Very fun read by the same author as Eats, Shoots and Leaves.

Katie
Katie 5pts

There is a term for this in psychology: The Bystander Effect.  It describes how a group of people, when witnessing a negative event, will delay action longer than an individual witnessing the same event alone.  In a group dynamic, the members look to the leader to initiate action.  When the group members are strangers or no clear leader is defined, the members of the group will take longer to act because of societal constraints. It's a terrible phenomenon, especially when the event in question is someone being hurt, but there are ways to counteract it.  The biggest one is to be the one to take charge.  Stand up and scream to stop an attack, run to an injured person's side, point to a specific person and tell them to call 911 rather than just yelling general instructions. It sounds like you're the kind of person to take charge in a situation, and the world needs more people like that.  Don't be afraid to act, but don't expect everyone else to suddenly change.  Just as the world needs those willing to take a stand, the world also needs those willing to follow.

Trackbacks

  1. Bearing Arms says:
    August 2, 2012 at 8:24 pm

    […] recently wrote an article about Moral Dystopia. People in crowds generally like to believe that “someone else” will take care of the problem. […]

  2. Kindness of Strangers says:
    August 14, 2012 at 7:03 pm

    […] though, I thought I’d skip back a few steps and review a previous post I did on Moral Dystopia. In this piece, I cried out to readers to step up the action and make me believe in human decency […]

  3. Under God says:
    August 30, 2012 at 3:00 pm

    […] What I don’t like is assholes. Guess that goes without saying, though. So let me try this again. […]

Stay in The World 4 Realz

Search The World Over

What In The World Were You Thinking?

  • Spafloating on In which Fucking February is no more. #ROW80 #IWSG #NaNoPrep
  • CarliGroven on In which Fucking February is no more. #ROW80 #IWSG #NaNoPrep
  • therealbirdman on How money works when you are poor
  • dthompson321 on Kansas – Your State SUCKS!
  • CarsonCanada on Oscar Prep is making me feel dirty.

Andi-Roo Wuz Here!

  • In which Fucking February is no more. #ROW80 #IWSG #NaNoPrep
  • Oscar Prep is making me feel dirty.
  • Fair enough. #ROW80
  • And that’s when shit got real – An ode to Depression.
  • Using a planner for #ROW80

AtoZ Challenge 2015

A Round of Words in 80 Days #ROW80

Insecure Writers Support Group #IWSG

Work In Progress: THE HEART OF THE GREENE

I Gots The Whole World Up In Here

Here Are My Cats. Not THOSE Cats. Stupid-Head.

Copyright © 2016 · Lifestyle Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in